Alternative Treatments for Allergies or Hay Fever
Photo by Mcfarlandmo
The term
'Allergies' means different things to different people. Many of us celebrate spring after a long cold
winter, but for one who suffers allergies to substances that trees or plants
produce in the spring, it isn't so pleasant.
For others, it may be fall that brings on the watery eyes, sneezing,
runny nose and other unpleasant symptoms of allergies. There are others who must avoid certain foods
such as peanuts, corn, eggs, dairy....and the list goes on and on. Due to the fact that the topic of allergies
is so vast, we are going to focus on seasonal allergies or hay fever in this article.
The Immune System
Photo by Jeanne Kelly
The immune
system is a very intricate system that is very powerful and in healthy
individuals it is extremely effective.
The medical explanation of allergies concludes that the immune system has
somehow malfunctioned and begins to produce antibodies against harmless
substances resulting in the unpleasant symptoms of allergies. The missing link in the medical model of
understanding is....they don't know why this happens. They blame the body as if it were not smart
enough to determine the difference between friend and foe. I see the body as highly intelligent and if
illness or symptoms arise there is good reason.
Before we jump into the 'whys' of allergies let's look at the physiology
of what is happening.
The mucous
membranes that line your respiratory tract contain immune cells called mast
cells. When a molecule of pollen, pet
dander, mold or another potential allergen enters into the nasal passage and latches
on to the mucous membrane those mast cells begin to
release histamines and other chemicals.
Histamines
trigger several mechanisms that are meant to rid the body of the foreign
substance. Allergy sufferers are
painfully aware of these mechanisms: Sneezing,
runny nose, watery eyes, itching. It is
generally called Hay Fever, or the medical term - allergic rhinitis.
Rather than
see this cascade of events as 'the immune system gone wrong.' I see it as an amazing manifestation of what
the body can do to protect us. The
sneezing, runny nose and other symptoms are triggered as the body is trying to
rid itself as something potentially harmful.
Well, maybe allergy sufferers might not share my same fascination with the
beauty of this particular set of symptoms.
In any case it is an amazing manifestation of just how miraculous the
body is and how it so intelligently functions to keep us healthy. Why do some of us experience allergies while
others do not?
The over-burdened body
Our bodies
are exposed to hundreds of chemicals on any given day. This is a heavy burden that our modern bodies
must handle. Throughout history people
lived in the natural world, today we live in a predominantly un-natural
world. That statement may seem odd, we
still live on earth which is the natural world but our connection to it is
entirely different.
Let's go
through a typical day in the life of a normal modern human being:
Wake up at 6
am and get in the shower, we use body wash, shaving gel, shampoo, conditioner, hair
spray, hair gel, lotion all of which contain a cocktail of harsh chemicals that
are absorbed directly through the skin.
Breakfast,
many of us overlook the fact that what we put in our bodies on a daily basis
can increase the level of inflammation in our bodies causing an even greater
stress on our delicate systems. Even
those who feel they eat a healthy breakfast may be unknowingly consuming foods
or chemicals that contribute to their suffering.
We go from
house, to car, to work. We are living
indoors most of the time and relying on recycled air, dirty filters and air
ducts. Do you see where I am going
here? The toxic burden on our modern
bodies is immense. Rather than do the
medical 'blame the body' game, I say our bodies are absolutely amazing at
handling the toxic burden we throw at them every single day!
There is
obviously a genetic tendency toward allergies, not everyone experiences allergies. Some people suffer from allergies from a
young age while many others develop allergies in their teens, or twenties.
The intensity of your allergies generally depends on how well your body
is able to handle the toxic burden you place on it every day. There comes a point where the body can no
longer handle the influx of incoming pollutants, chemicals and toxins and it
becomes overburdened, as we tip the scales beyond the body's ability to cope
normally we begin to experience symptoms.
Those symptoms mainly depend upon our genetic weaknesses.
Do you
realize that there are over 3000 chemicals that may be added to the food you
eat? Your body is tasked with figuring
out how to detoxify and get rid of all of these chemicals on a regular basis...that
is a HUGE job!
If you
thought that seemed like an insurmountable task, consider the fact that there
are over 70,000 chemicals in use today for everything from cleaning, cosmetics,
pesticides, added to our water.....and the list goes on and on. All of the exposure to processed food-like
substances, chemicals at every turn our bodies are going to have chronic
low-grade inflammation that is going to manifest itself in a host of ways. Is it any wonder our bodies begin to react to
substances that aren't truly harmful?
Typical Causes of Allergic Rhinitis
Seasonal allergic rhinitis is triggered by pollen and
mold spores. Sources include:
- Ragweed -- the most common seasonal allergen (fall)
- Grass pollen, in late spring and summer
- Tree pollen, in spring
- Fungus, mold growing on dead leaves, common in summer and fall
Year-round allergic rhinitis may be triggered by:
- Pet dander
- Dust and household mites
- Cockroaches
- Molds growing on wall paper, house plants, carpeting, and upholstery
Allergy Testing
Conventional
medicine has specific tests to identify what you may be allergic to.
Tests
include:
Scratch test
for IgE antibody response
Radioallergosorbent
test or RAST
Blood tests
that measure IgE
ELISA tests
are more accurate in detecting all sensitivities as they will measure both IgE
and IgG antibodies.
ALCAT is
another test that measures the response of the white blood cells to a whole
panel of allergens. This is the most
comprehensive form of allergen testing.
Conventional Treatments
Treatments
for allergic rhinitis include antihistamine medications such as clemastine
(Tavist™) and nasal corticosteroids like fluticasone (Flonase™). While these
drugs can offer significant relief from allergy symptoms, clemastine may cause
undesirable side effects including dry mouth, drowsiness, and anemia, and
fluticasone can cause serious allergic reactions.
Risks according to the package insert
of Flonase:
Intranasal
corticosteroids may cause a reduction in growth velocity when administered
to
pediatric patients.
Chickenpox
and measles, for example, can have a more
serious or
even fatal course in susceptible children or adults using corticosteroids.
Rare
instances of wheezing, nasal septum perforation,
cataracts,
glaucoma, and increased intraocular pressure have been reported following the
intranasal
application of corticosteroids, including fluticasone propionate.
Pregnancy
Category C. Subcutaneous studies in the
mouse
and rat 4 times, respectively, the
maximum recommended daily intranasal dose in adults on a mcg/m2 basis),
revealed
fetal toxicity characteristic of potent corticosteroid compounds, including
embryonic
growth
retardation, omphalocele, cleft palate, and retarded cranial ossification.
In
the rabbit, fetal weight reduction and cleft palate were observed at a subcutaneous
dose of 4
mcg/kg
(less than the maximum recommended daily intranasal dose in adults on a mcg/m2
basis).
Alternative Treatments
Photo by Kurt Yoder
Nasal
irrigation with saline solution -In
2013, an Italian study published in the International Archives of Allergy and Immunology found that
nasal flushing was a mild and effective way to treat seasonal allergies in
children, and markedly reduced their use of antihistamines.
Nutrition and Dietary Supplements
Click the
link below for an excellent article on foods that help reduce the symptoms of
nasal allergies:
Dr. Christophers Dietary
Recommendations include:
A
plant-based diet is the ideal diet for those suffering with allergies. Avoid allergenic foods as well including
dairy, eggs, refined wheat products. The
diet should include plenty of fruits and vegetables, whole grains, and
legumes. Eating a clean diet of whole
foods is key.
Consumption of fruits and
vegetables - Studies have shown a reduction in
symptoms with the consumption of fruits and vegetables in relation to allergic
rhinitis. http://erj.ersjournals.com/content/22/5/772.short
Avoid Processed foods- If the label contains something you can't pronounce...don't eat it!
It is important to avoid all processed foods. Make sure your diet consists largely of fruits, vegetables, brown rice, lentils, beans.....healthy whole foods.
Remove dairy products - A report published by the American Academy of Allergy and Immunology
Committee on Adverse Reactions to Food, the allergies of up to 30% of children tested resolved after milk was removed from their diet.
The well-known Dr. Benjamin Spock said:
"Cow's milk is not recommended for a child when he is sick or when he is well, for that matter. Dairy products may cause more mucus complications and cause more discomfort with upper respiratory infections."
Dr. Michael Klapper explains the physiological details of how milk increases mucus production:
"When the protein of another animal is introduced into one's immune system, an allergic/immune response is created in many places in the body. A common reaction to such an assault by a foreign protein in our immune system is an outpouring of mucus from the nasal and throat membranes. The resulting mucus flow can create the chronic runny noses, persistent sore throats, hoarseness, bronchitis, and recurrent ear infections that plague so many children, and their parents."
"In reality, cow's milk, especially processed cow's milk, has been linked to a variety of health
problems, including: mucous production...and allergies."
Townsend Medical Letter, May, 1995, Julie Klotter, MD
"Dairy products may play a major
role in the development of allergies, asthma, sleep difficulties,
and migraine headaches."
Israel Journal of Medical Sciences 1983; 19(9):806-809
Drink
water - Many children are given fruit juice, soda, milk and other beverages but
they are rarely offered water.
Unfortunately, after developing a taste for sweet drinks many children
refuse to drink water and this can lead to chronic dehydration and aggravates
asthma and allergies.
Supplements
that may lessen Symptoms
- Probiotics -- A study in Clinical
& Experimental Allergy concluded, "Changes in antigen-induced
production of cytokines were observed in patients treated with
probiotics. These data show that
probiotic supplementation modulates immune responses in allergic Rhintiis
and may have the potential to alleviate the severity of symptoms."1
- Flavonoids including
Quercitin -- 1000 mg./day An article written
in Allergology International states, "Flavonoids, ubiquitously
present in vegetables, fruits and teas possess anti-allergenic
activities. Flavonoids inhibit
histamine release, synthesis of IL-4 and IL-3 and CD40 ligand expression
by basophils." Consumption of
a wide variety of fruits and vegetables is critical in those who suffer
from allergic rhinitis. Additional
supplementation of flavonoids may also be beneficial.2
- Spirulina -- Preliminary test
tube and animal studies suggest that spirulina, a type of blue-green
algae, may help protect against harmful allergic reactions. Spirulina stops
the release of histamine, which contribute to symptoms of allergic
rhinitis. But researchers don’t know whether it would work in people.
Herbs
The use of herbs is a time-honored approach to
strengthening the body and treating disease. Herbs, however, can trigger side
effects and can interact with other herbs, supplements, or medications. For
these reasons, you should take herbs only under the supervision of a health
care practitioner.
- Butterbur (Petasites
hybridus, 500 mg per day) --A study published in the British Medical Journal in 2002 concluded
that Butterbur was as effective as Cetirizene in treating allergic
rhinitis. Patients in this study
were given 1 tablet of butterbur 4 times per day.
Another study published in Clinical
and Experimental Allergy compared Butterbur to the allergy drug
Fexofenadine. Researchers in this study
also concluded that Butterbur was just as effective in reducing symptoms of
seasonal allergies.3,4
- Stinging nettle (Urtica
dioica, 600 mg per day) -- An article published in Phytotherapy Research
details the mechanistic understanding of the constituents of stinging
nettle and how they contribute to the inhibition of
pro-inflammatory pathways related to allergic rhinitis. 5
- Tinospora cordifolia (300 mg three times daily) -- A study randomized
double-blind placebo controleld study published in Ethnopharmacology found
that tinospora cardifolia significantly
decreased all symptoms of allergic rhinitis. Nasal smear cytology and
leukocyte count correlated with clinical findings. Tinospora is contraindicated for those
with diabetes, Crohn's disease, and auto-immune diseases.6
- Astragalus (Astragalus
membranaceus, 160 mg two times per day) -- A study published in Phytotherapy
Research found that Astragalus Compared to placebo, HMC
significantly decreased the intensity of rhinorrhea. Researchers state that they saw a
significant improvement in many aspects of the patients symptoms.7
Homeopathy
It is important to understand that in order for a
homeopathic remedy to be effective it must be prescribed VERY specifically to
the individual, taking into account the 'whole person'. Meaning the homeopath
evaluates for your constitutional type including not only the physical symptoms
but emotional, mental and psychological aspects of the illness as well. An
experienced homeopath assesses all of these factors when determining the most
appropriate treatment for you but if you would like to try a lower dose, over
the counter remedy, these remedies are commonly used for allergic rhinitis.
- Nux vomica -- for
stuffiness with nasal discharge, watery nasal discharge, restless hay
fever, burning mucus that blocks the nose at night, frequent sneezing, dry, ticklish, and scraping nasal
sensations; an appropriate person for this remedy is irritable and
impatient, careful, zealous, very particular individuals.
- Arsenicum album -- Headaches, burning pains,
intense chilliness, anxious or hypersensitive nerves, restlessness,
anxiousness, and weariness dominate this remedy’s applications. Arsenicum
has a strong effect on mucus membranes, Arsenicum relieves
allergies, hay fever and severe colds or flu with sneezing, coughing and
watery, burning secretions. Its coughs hack, wheeze, dry up at night,
loosen during the day with frothy, salty, burning mucus, copious, burning
nasal discharge, violent sneezing.
- Allium cepa --Burning watery eyes, frequent sneezing, copious irritating nasal discharge and tearing
eyes; this person tends to feel thirsty. Symptoms are better in the open air.
- Euphrasia -- feeling of dryness, inflammation and stinging in
their eyes. In such cases, the eyes water profusely almost always and the
water has a pungent smell, bland nasal
discharge, with stinging, hot reddened cheeks, irritating tears; a suitable person for
this remedy has worse nasal symptoms when lying down.
References:
1. Ivory, K., Chambers, S.
J., Pin, C., Prieto, E., Arqués, J. L. and Nicoletti, C. (2008), Oral delivery
of Lactobacillus casei Shirota
modifies allergen-induced immune responses in allergic rhinitis. Clinical &
Experimental Allergy, 38: 1282–1289.
doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2222.2008.03025.x
2. http://ai.jsaweb.jp/fulltext/056020113/056020113_index.html
3. BMJ 2002; 324 doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.324.7330.144 (Published 19
January 2002)
4.
Lee, D. K. C., Gray, R. D., Robb, F. M., Fujihara, S. and Lipworth, B. J.
(2004), A placebo-controlled evaluation of butterbur and fexofenadine on
objective and subjective outcomes in perennial allergic rhinitis. Clinical
& Experimental Allergy, 34: 646–649.
doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2222.2004.1903.x
5.
Roschek, B., Fink, R. C., McMichael, M. and Alberte, R. S. (2009), Nettle
extract (Urtica dioica) affects key
receptors and enzymes associated with allergic rhinitis. Phytother. Res.,
23: 920–926. doi: 10.1002/ptr.2763
6. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S037887410400474X
7. Matkovic,
Z., Zivkovic, V., Korica, M., Plavec, D., Pecanic, S. and Tudoric, N. (2010),
Efficacy and safety of Astragalus membranaceus
in the treatment of patients with seasonal allergic rhinitis. Phytother. Res.,
24: 175–181. doi: 10.1002/ptr.2877